| 1913: | Commissioner John Price Jackson | 1968: | John K. Tabor |
| 1919: | Commissioner Clifford B. Connelley | 1969: | Clifford L. Jones |
| 1923: | Commissioner Royal Meeker | 1970: | Theodore Robb |
| 1925: | Richard H. Lansburgh | 1971: | Paul J. Smith |
| 1927: | Charles A. Waters | 1979: | Myron L. Joseph |
| 1929: | Peter Glick | 1979: | Charles J. Lieberth |
| 1931: | Arthur Miller Northrop | 1981: | Barry H. Stern |
| 1933: | Charlotte E. Carr | 1984: | James W. Knepper Jr. |
| 1935: | Edward Noel Jones | 1987: | Harris Wofford |
| 1935: | Ralph Moody Bashore | 1991: | Thomas Patrick Foley |
| 1939: | Lewis G. Hines | 1994: | Robert S. Barnett |
| 1943: | William H. Chesnut | 1995: | Johnny J. Butler |
| 1951: | David M. Walker | 2003: | Stephen M. Schmerin |
| 1955: | John R. Torquato | 2008: | Sandi Vito |
| 1957: | William L. Batt, Jr. | 2011: | Julia K. Hearthway |
| 1961: | A. Allen Sulcowe | 2015: | Kathy Manderino |
| 1963: | William P. Young | 2017: | W. Gerard "Jerry" Oleksiak |
| 1967: | William Joseph Hart | 2020:
| Jennifer Berrier |
